WiFiReview.com
HOME  |  CONTACT US
Username Password Forgot password |  Register |  Logout
D-Link DWL-G650 Wireless Cardbus Adapter, 802.11g, 108Mbps
D-Link DWL-G650 Wireless Cardbus Adapter, 802.11g, 108Mbps
enlarge
Model: DWL-G650
Brand: D-Link
Manufacturer: D-Link
Average Rating:    (submit your review here)
Total Reviews: 143
Form factor: Plug-in module
Hardware platform: PC
Data link protocol: IEEE 802.11b, IEEE 802.11, IEEE 802.11g
 
Features:
Up to 108 Mbps with AirPlus Xtreme G products
Backwards compatible with 802.11b and 802.11g
Great for video streaming
Enhanced security from 802.1x and WPA for better encrypted key management and authentication
3-year warranty
 
Description:
The D-Link AirPlus DWL-G650 Cardbus Adapter is a wireless cardbus featuring the very latest in advanced wireless silicon chip technology including enhanced security to shield and protect your wireless communication from intruders. The DWL-G650 also works with 802.11b standard wireless devices and when used with other D-Link AirPlus Xtreme G products delivers throughput speeds capable of handling heavy data payloads including real-time MPEG 4 video streaming.The DWL-G650 features 802.1x for wireless user authentication, as well as WPA (Wi-Fi Protected Access) providing you a much higher level of security for your data and communications than has previously been available in a wireless networking solution.The D-Link AirPlus DWL-G650 also includes a configuration utility to discover available wireless networks and create and save detailed connectivity profiles for those networks most often accessed.The DWL-G650 is a powerful 32-bit cardbus adapter that installs quickly and easily into laptop PCs and when used with other D-Link AirPlus Xtreme G products automatically connects to the network. Like all D-Link wireless adapters, the DWL-G650 can be used in ad-hoc mode to connect directly with other cards for peer-to-peer file sharing or in infrastructure mode to connect with a wireless access point or router for access to the Internet in your office or home network.
 
User Reviews (143 total):
Page   1  2  3  4  5  6  7     of Total 7 Pages


    XP or 2000 only., April 21, 2004
By unknown
The card says it works with windows 98. Not for me. After fiddling with it for about 10 hours, I installed it in a Win2000 notebook. Worked right away. I also installed the updated driver from Dlink (108Mbs support) and I was dropping the connection every 15 minutes. Went back to the original driver included in the CD-ROM.

This card, with the DI-624 router works fantanstic. Setup was easy and trhe wireless connection is 15% faster than the wired 10baseT port on the speed sites. Works fine in any area of the house as well. WEP encryption was easy to setup.

    ************ Avoid D-Link Products ********************, April 19, 2004
By Fred Sanders (Austin, TX)
The product may perform up to your expectations but I only hope you never have to interact with D-Link's support organization. After dealing with conflicting, contradictory and completely erroneous information from their support organization, I have come to the conclusion that I don't care to do business with D-Link again.

I hope that if you do buy a D-Link product it works flawlessly (which mine did not), and you never have to call their tech support organization.

    Card causes my laptop to freeze, April 18, 2004
By unknown
When using this card my laptop freezes without any apparent reason. Sometimes it freezes immediately - sometimes after hours of use. All I can do is to reboot the laptop.

Sent the card to D-Link and got a replacement but it still wouldn't work. Updating drivers doesn't help either.

    Make sure u have the latest revision - read for more info..., April 14, 2004
By Ali Mohamad (Issaquah, WA USA)
First, you must know that D-Link has the annoying and unprofessional habit of releasing unfinished, not so ready hardware to market. It seems that their engineering team is under pressure from marketing (typical) to deliver products before they are completely tested and ready. There are several revisions (internal designs) of this and other D-Link products. As of this writing (April 2004), the DWL-G650 has 7 of them, A1, B1, B2, B3, B4, C1, and C2 each representing a correction to a "Oops" of some sort! The DWL-G520 has 2, A and B, while the DI-624 router has 3, A, B, and C. The latest revision is what you should look for, it is usually on the sticker on the back of the box - just below the serial number.

OK, so I had the DI-614+ router, DWL-650+ PC Card, and DWL-520+ PCI card, and they worked great. I just needed the higher speed to stream music and video from my server upstairs, and wanted to use the more secure WPA protocol (not yet supported on the DWL-520+ *stupid D-Link*), so I upgraded to the DI-624 router (rev. C), DWL-G650 PC Card (rev. B4), and DWL-G520 PCI Card (rev. B). I upgraded the firmware on the router right away to 2.42 and the driver for the G650 to 2.48. The router seemed to work fine, but the card was not seeing it. My older 802.11B card (DWL-650+) was able to see and connect to the new router, but not the new card. I tried many things to no avail. I then installed the older driver 2.42 and the card started seeing the router but had trouble keeping the connection..I played with many settings and nothing helped. I tried two other laptops (different brands) and experienced the same symptoms.
Finally, I went to the a store and purchased another DWL-G650 and made sure it was the newer rev. C2 (the latest). Guess what, it worked right away and kept the connection solid. I tried FTP between the server (wired to the router) and the wireless laptop and got a transfer throughput of about 2400KBytes/sec... This is while using WPA-PSK with Super G enabled and using a short preamble. The same results were obtained with the PCI version of the card (DWL-G520).
I returned the bad PC Card (rev. B4) back to the store and kept the new one! So, just make sure that you have the latest version of the hardware.

One more thing, if you compare the signal quality/strength between DWL-650+ and DWL-G650 or between DWL-520+ and DWL-G520 you'll find that the new cards have a much lower number (worst). For example, my old 650+ used to get around 70% quality compared to 36% for the G650 at the same exact spot/direction. The difference is identical when comparing the 520+ to the G520. I have not experienced any performance issues though, the TxRate is typically at 72Mbps (not 108Mbps)! I think the new AirPlus XtremeG utility calculates the quality number differently and hence the difference, and future driver updates may further enhance the signal measurement.

D-Link's release of faulty hardware is wrong and must be stopped. The problem is that their competition are not much better. So go for what works, and buy from a place that has a good return policy. Someday another vendor will make better products and offer better support, and I will abandon D-Link :)

    Great wireless card!, March 30, 2004
By S. Chi (Princeton, NJ)
This card works best with the DI-624 router. I have Windows 2000 and have not had any problems after upgrading to the latest firmware. Signal strength and range are good, and card does not overheat after prolonged usage.

Just a few things to keep in mind.

1) Download the latest firmware BEFORE you hook up your wireless connection. Do this on your wired connection- the DI-624 wireless router has both wired and wireless connections.

2) Install the latest firmware. The card would also only work in a specific PCMCIA slot that I had installed it in.

3) Disable any internal builtin wireless cards in your laptop.

Happy surfing.

    No Fuss, No Muss. This card FULL blazes - freestyle!, March 25, 2004
By unknown
If I went off of other reviewers information, I would never have purchased this sweet product. After reading other reviews I decided to disregard them and just finally buy it. I plugged it into my Dell Latitude w/ Windows 2000 Professional. Coupled w/ a D-Link DI-624 Router, SBC DSL, and I'm full blazin' the net, freestyle. I have a cordless phone 2.4Ghz... no problems w/ interference. Was plug and play, all the way. If you can install software programs, you can install this.

    Do not buy for use with an HP or Compaq laptop!, March 22, 2004
By Ryan Harvey (Portland, Oregon; United States)
This is the second D-Link PCMIA card I've owned, and they have both been good performers, except they interfere with Windows' power management features on HP and Compaq notebooks. I thought the problem would be solved by buying this newer card, but it hasn't. My computer refuses to stay powered on for more than 20 minutes unattended, and frequently, when browsing the Internet, my mouse cursor freezes and the only way out is to hit the power button. I did some online research, and it turns out many other HP and Compaq laptop users have had the same problem. For some reason, these incompatibilities still exist, despite D-Link knowing about them for some time.

Again, D-Link cards perform well and are a good value, but I would not recommend one to an HP or Compaq user.

    works really well, March 13, 2004
By Dickey (Boston, MA USA)
I think most of my frustration is due to my ISP, but this thing has been great really. The best feature doesn't even come in the box, but the tech support is phenomenal. I spent a bit of time on hold, but the guy I spoke with had me up and running in no time at all.

In general, the setup is easy (I'm using it with the D-Link DI-624). The program installs everything for you, I ran into trouble after my ISP shut down my service for some foolish reason and made me change some settings which I guess messed with my network setup. In any case, this comes highly recommended for anyone that wants to set up a wireless network, even if you aren't particularly computer savvy, as I am not.

    Poor Range, March 10, 2004
By 2explore (Miami, FL United States)
I decided to replace my DI-704P wired network, which I had no problems with but just wanted wireless with my notebook. So bought the DI-624 along with the DWL-G650. I live in a two story house. In the room with the router the reception was excellent (I used Netstumbler and Cirond WiNc), but in the next room signal strength dropped to 75%, 50% in the third bedroom, downstairs 25% and outside under the bedroom with the router 15-20%. These numbers all seemed low. So I replaced both units with the same results. However, the story has a happy ending.... Again, I replaced both units but with the Netgear WGR614 router and the WG511 notebook. All I can say is D-Link has "POOR RANGE". With the Netgear setup - signal strength was above 75% anywhere in the house and outside opposite side as the router it was still 60%. The D-Link units need work! In addition, with SSID broadcast off and the WEP at 128bit the D-Link card could not find the network. Netgear had no problems. I found this review of the Netgear WG511 on Cnet's website. It shows the Throughput/Performance of 5 different cards including the D-Link and Netgear cards ---- http://reviews.cnet.com/4505-3251_7-21056546.html?tag=txt ----Hope this helps you make an informed decision.

    NETGEAR STUFF - Specific - MR814 Router, March 9, 2004
By petrinam (Royal Oak, MI United States)
Duration of Ownership: 10 Months

Strengths:

works well as a wired router

Weaknesses:

wireless is so unpredictable but most of the time down

Summary:

I have this router for almost a year and I was never able to use it for its wireless fetures more then a few hours at a time, and only once. It usually drops the connection after 10 minutes. Then it does not work for days.

Customer support is really bad, they give you the run-around trying to save a buck replacing the unit. They blame your wireless computer for it and want you to upgrade everything like there is no tomorrow. (My wireless worked well with other networks, and even in the house "sees" a neighbour's wireless network). I really wasted 1 hour on the phone with them so they told me (after on hold most of the time) they will connect me with level 2 technician. Probably somebody smarter at the run-around.

THIS WAS MY FOURTH AND LAST CALL TO CUSTOMER SERVICE AND I TOLD TO THEM HANG UP BECAUSE THEY MIGHT BE ABLE TO "HELP" SOMEBODY ELSE (WHO IS PROBABLY ON HOLD FOR HALF AN HOUR). These were totally 3 hours wasted.

I will never buy from NETGEAR again. (I have a 15 year experience with computers.)

Thank you!

    I ended up going back to my old Netgear card, March 7, 2004
By jwu (San Jose, CA USA)
This card would not work with the 624 router. I keep losing the connection and then the router would disappear from my list of available networks, while my neighbor's network two doors down seems stronger than ever.

Switched back to my old 22mbps Netgear card and the network has been stable so far. Not as fast, but at least it works and doesn't drop me.

    fast, March 5, 2004
By Elliot Hertzbach (Houston, tx United States)
Extremely fast tranfer of files between computers, 123meg file in 67 seconds with computers about 150' apart
D/L from internet at 105K/sec on my dsl line same speed as my desktop. Setup was confusing still not optimized and don't have security enabled yet. Overall great for the price


    Mostly great..., February 29, 2004
By Ryan (Los Angels, CA USA)
The great: Near the base it is very fast. Far from the base, it works farther than my old 802.11b did, and even at that range I get better speed than I got with my old gear close to the base. :)

The unsure: I don't know for sure if its the base station or the card (I think base), but every once in a while, the connection will just drop. Windows will still show a link, but pings ect (to the base or anywhere) just fail).

May or may not matter to you: No external antenna connector. There are ways to "install" one if you really need one, you can find at least two pages via google. Linux drivers - no distro comes with working drivers, and d-link doesn't provide a driver or support. You need to go here: http://sourceforge.net/projects/madwifi/ and compile the stuff. And it doesn't get you full functionality. - so if you are in linux most of the time, you should probably pick another card. Me, I'm in 2k most of the time with my notebook, so the linux support is workable. I'm happy.

    Seems to not like WIN98, February 27, 2004
By unknown
I had the chance to purchase a B but decided to ride the NEW edge and get the G650 (Oct 2003). But when I plugged it in, it would not connect up to the LinkSys Router A/B. I had a friend try it at his house which was using the D-link of another version, and mine would not work on his PC either. He reloaded drivers even, no dice. He put his existing card back in and loaded fine. I returned mine. Second one, junk condition from D-Link considering mine was mint having never been used in a working mode! It gave me a different error altogether. I had a co-worker try it on his laptop with WIN98, but it didn't work there either, we tried various drivers. I then got a laptop with WIN2000 and it couldn't load it either. Returned this one 2 days ago. Hopefully my next one will work? The co-worker was using yet a newer version of D-link G650, which had issues also. I really am sorry I didn't go B at this point in time. I only hope d-link will come through with try 3.

    Finally Got it Working Good, February 23, 2004
By Jeffrey Liss (NYC)
I bought the DWL-G650 card (Version B4) along with the the 624 Router (Version C1) about 5 weeks ago. I found it very hard to set up. XP Professional was installing its own drivers and would not recognize the D-Link drivers. It took me about 10 hours to resolve that issue. Customer support at D-Link was of no help. Then I had a dropped connection problem and a slow web surfing issue. I recently resolved that issue by upgrading my cable modem for free to a Toshiba PCX 2600. I was using a Toshiba PCX 1000. My point here is that there are so many factors that determine how this card will work for you. I'm getting 108mbps and hope I can continue to enjoy these fast speeds. It's no fun trying to fix things all the time.

    Horrible software, reasonable hardware, February 23, 2004
By VSOP (Pelotas, Brazil)
I bought the g650 with the DI-624 router. It was a disappointment. I could not get the card to see the wireless network, after having followed the installation instructions step by step. After much fiddling I found out that doing exactly the opposite of what was said let me connect to the router, after all. That is, disabling the "utility" and using windows to configure the wireless network. After that, despite getting the card to work, I was disappointed with range, speed, and reliability of the signal. I use Win XP Pro, and maybe the software problems are specific to this version. Anyway, the other card I have (TrendNet) works much better, even with D-Link's own router. And just as the last drop, the indicator lights are far too big, and keep blinking all the time, what is enerving and distracting. Ah! They do not work as described in the manual...

As a result of all this, including not being able to get all my house covered, I'm back to my blue wires...

    Should not have switched brands, February 21, 2004
By flivver_99 (Hancock, MI United States)
All of my wired networks are with Netgear products and I should have stayed with them. A local electronics store was having a sale on D-Link products, and I wanted to go wireless, so I figured I'd give them a shot. I did a little research on the Internet with OK reviews for this card (apparently for the "A" & "C" versions) and the DI-624 router, which I also have. Everything worked fine until I got the latest windows ME updates and now the card does not work at all. I tried both both the drivers that came with the card (v. 2.23) and the latest (2.48), but I can not connect to any wireless networks (and I've tried many). It turns out that I got stuck with the "B" version of the card, which a lot of other people are having problems with. I'm just hoping I will not have to replace both the router and the card, although my friends have been able to connect to my routher with other cards without any problems. Needless to say, I just ordered a new Netgear wireless card and I am not expecting any problems. My current Netgear wired PC adapter is nearly 5 years old and I have never had any problems with it.

    Crashes Often!!, February 20, 2004
By Joshua Allen (Seattle, WA United States)
I bought one of these last week brand new, and will probably have to return it. The 108Mbps is great, but the card crashes my machines frequently. I have two toshiba tablet PCs, both freshly installed with Windows XP, and the card bluescreens either one at least once a day. It also often simply quits working, and requires a reboot to detect my d-link access points again. On install with the very latest drivers, it complains that the drivers are not signed by Microsoft, which should be a warning. They seem to be very crappy stability, these would never sell in Japan.

    A Great Wireless Adapter, February 19, 2004
By Judy (Chicago, IL)
Following the instructions was never an easy thing for me to do, but when you do it right, installation is a snap. The speeds for this card are good, even when not coupled with a D-Link wireless access point. The security is easy to use and quite secure. The range is also a plus for this card. I can be anywhere in my office and still recieve an Internet connection. This is great for when I have meetings and I bring my laptop to meetings.

I give this card 5 stars because it deserves it. I had zero problems, and am very pleased with it's performance.

    Terrible device drivers, February 19, 2004
By unknown
There's a reason why this card is so cheap and offers a rebate. It will waste endless hours of your time getting it to work.

The people that gave this card good reviews either (1) are not using encryption, or (2) don't have revision B of the card.

I started out with the original drivers under WinMe. But I was frustrated because it would never remember my encryption settings. Also, I wanted to experience the much-touted "108Mps", so I downloaded the latest drivers. After that, nothing worked. The new drivers are complete junk. I'm a software professional, and I spent about 24 hours over the last 3 days trying to get the updated drivers to work.

I'm currently using the old driver and the newer Utility (which you use to set it up and see what speeds you're getting).

It's unbelievable that such a well-known and well-respected (?) company as D-Link would put out such a bad product. The hardware may be good, but it's useless without decent drivers.

Pay the extra money and buy a better card. I wish I had.

Page   1  2  3  4  5  6  7     of Total 7 Pages


Submit your review

Submit review form is only available to logged in users.

Summary (150 chars max)

Review

What is your location (for example: US, New Jersey)

Item Rating
1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars

Copyright 2001-2007 WiFiReview.com