WiFiReview.com
HOME  |  CONTACT US
Username Password Forgot password |  Register |  Logout
Linksys BEFW11S4 Wireless-B Cable/DSL Router
Linksys BEFW11S4 Wireless-B Cable/DSL Router
enlarge
Model: BEFW11S4
Brand: Linksys
Manufacturer: Linksys
Average Rating:    (submit your review here)
Total Reviews: 1079
Platforms: Windows NT, Windows 98, Windows 2000, Windows NT 3.5, Windows NT 4, Windows NT 5, Windows Me, Windows XP, Windows 2000 Server, Windows
Operating system: None
Form factor: External
Hardware platform: PC
Data link protocol: Ethernet, Fast Ethernet, IEEE 802.11b
 
Features:
Connects to a broadband modem, a 10/100 Ethernet backbone, or wireless network
Long wireless operating range supports 300 feet indoors and 1,500 feet outdoors
Provides roaming, best access-point selection, load balancing, and network traffic filtering
Configurable through your networked PC's Web browser
Can act as a DHCP server for your existing network
 
Description:
The Linksys BEFW11S4 is your all-in-one networking device This wireless router features support for the 802.11b protocol, which lets you wirelessly access your network and the Internet from up to 800 feet (outside), or 300 feet (inside) away
 
User Reviews (1079 total):
Page   23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50     of Total 50 Pages


    A breakthrough product - flawless execution, December 3, 2001
By Rick Minto (Sterling Heights, MI United States)
This is a 3-in-1 product: an Ethernet router and four-port switch combined with an 802.11b compliant wireless access point. It connects to your computer's Ethernet card (another other computers' NICs) on one side with an RJ-45 plug and to your cablemodem on the other side with coaxial cable. I am using it to connect to two other computers in the house with Category 5 Ethernet cable and to my IBM Thinkpad laptop, which has Linksys' WPC11 wireless network card.

Configuring the device to work with your cable ISP and computer is very easy. The instructions are straightforward, and the basic tools you need to get up and running in minutes are easy to find in the browser interface. (A stroke of genius). A hookup video is included on CD-ROM. I ran the CD from my laptop while hooking up the desktop.

There is alot more that this device can do than most average users (like me) with probably need.

Since the router part uses network address translation to split your cable feed into multiple other data streams, it works as a firewall. Other computers can't see the network addresses "behind" the router. I dumped BlackIce Defender as a software firewall for incoming intrusions is not needed. You will probably still want a firewall for out-bound traffic (sent from cookies, snoopware, trojans, etc.) like Sygate personal firewall 4.2.

At this time, Linksys wireless card does not come with XP drivers, but Windows 2000 drivers seem to work fine.

The antenna's range is pretty good. There is only one spot in one room at the opposite end of the house where I loose the connection. The speed is slower than direct cable connection for transferring files over the LAN, but Web page speed from a cable modem is just as fast over the wireless link as over the cat 5 lines. I would be careful using wireless devices INSTEAD of cat 5 cable to hook up desktop PCs, though -- make sure you can get a strong signal path to the transmitter. Laptops' antennae don't have the same directional sensitivity issues that desktop wireless antennae do.

All in all, the device works great. You can dump your secondary IP address and save money from your IP. If you have a cable modem and two or more PCs and a laptop and want to share printers, files and high-speed internet access, this is truly a must-have product.

    Easy Home Network, December 2, 2001
By unknown
For a non-techy relatively easy to install and set-up to replace "hard-wire" DSL arrangement. Instructions were clear and helpful.

    A great value play! Linksys has the Formula., December 1, 2001
By Velocipede (USA)
I'll admit, I was very skeptical of this wireless wunderkind when I read the first reviews. A relatively cheap alternative to a hard-wired home network but would it work reliably? The answer is an overwhelming YES. I've read many of the other reviews here denegrating this router's performance and mechanics. Maybe I'm just lucky but I've been very pleased with this wireless peripheral.

Including the required purchase of a wireless network card, this all-in-one peripheral provides a wireless PC connection as well as wired Ethernet PCs access to a single broadband Net connection. This wireless router allows for sharing of IP addresses, files, printers, and other network resources (I use this product specifically for a wireless high-speed Net connection to my desktop PC cable connection...I have my Compaq Presario 1200 notebook (WIN ME) networked to my Gateway P5 desktop (WIN 98v2) without compatability issues).

This router works extremely well without dropping the connection well within the distance limitations reflected in the Linksys documentation (although the advertised 400 ft. maximum would be pushing it well past the envelope in my opinion). I have tested these distance limitations extensively. My desktop/router is located in my upstairs office while I operate my notebook downstairs. Estimating, I suspect the working distance is easily 150 lineal feet with several walls and a floor to pass through. To test these limitations further, I've even taken the notebook to my garage with limited degradation (the length/signal strength icon moved to "yellow" signifying a questionable link albeit workable).

As with any shared connection, you'll see some speed degradation (as compared to the hard-wired primary desktop) from time-to-time but not enough to really matter. Many purists will disagree with me but this fixed, one-time cost beats the cost of hard-wiring a home network and monthly cable costs any time. Amortizing the hard costs relative to monthly cable costs (and initial installation) can be achieved in a minimum of 4 months in many cases depending on location and service providers (i.e. after 4 months, you're dollars ahead!)

Conclusion: a very solid wireless perhipheral for those desiring a second cable/DSL connection without the monthly cost. An outstanding value.

    Needs rebooting., November 30, 2001
By Robert Tsai (Boston, MA USA)
I owned it for a few weeks. Every day or two I'd have to reboot it. The DHCP server tends to hold on to leased addresses even after the client goes away and reconnects (couldn't they see that the same MAC address has come back?). The configuration options are rather basic; if you have a networking background (e.g., your former firewall was a Linux or BSD box), this is probably not the box for you. Finally, it (like most other home routers) only supports one IPSec pass-through session.

Instead, I highly recommend the Nexland ISB WaveBase. It costs a lot more, but is very well worth it, especially for the concurrent IPSec session support.

    Easy to setup and worked like a charm with cable modem., November 29, 2001
By unknown
Just plugged it in and everything worked. The only thing you need to configure (if you want to) is the WEP encryption for your wireless card. I am using a Lucent Orinoco Silver PC Card and it flies.

I got a better wireless connection (at 100 feet away) when I pointed the two antennas toward each other (creating an upside-down V). I even used my 900mhz phone, used two Nextel's Direct Connect and there was no interference whatsoever.

Even if you are not a network expert, the manual is very easy to read and the configuration through your browser is easy to understand as well.

    BEFW11S4 - A blue angel if you know how to make it work., November 29, 2001
By wu chou (Basking Ridge, NJ United States)
BEFW11S4 from Linksys is a great product and has the right package for home and workgroup use. I bought two of them, one for lab and one for home. I would like it to have a larger range, but my wife thinks it's safer for use at home.

The set-up menu is adequate for connection with fixed IP. But connection with dynamic IP, such as some cable modem,can be a big problem. It took me 5 min at lab and two weeks at home.Just before I was about to return it, I read my last email (...)and in it, a possible solution. And this time,it works. Thinking this maybe useful for other people like myself, I list the key steps below:
(1) Connect a computer directly to the cable modem FIRST and using ipconfig /all to obtain all information of the cable modem and its position on the network (i.e.MAC/Physical, gateway, DNS, etc.) and write them carefully down.
(2) At BEFW11S4 setup, goto Clone Mac address page under advanced on firmware's 1.36t6 and higher.Change the user defined Mac address to the Mac address you have recorded (These are additional steps beyond those which you have to do by the menu).

The rest is standard using the information of (1) and dynamic IP option. Then it will fly like an angel !!!

    Working fine in Guadalajara, Mexico, November 26, 2001
By Jose Burgos (San Diego, California United States)
I bought this router 2 weeks ago, it had a nice price and rebate...I installed it at my home, first in San Diego, CA and then in Guadalajara, Mexico, and after plugging the right cables and making a phone call to my cable company in order to configure the WAN, it has been working really fine...I have a Linksys PCMCIA card working with my two laptops: Dell Inspiron 8000 and HP Pavilion 5470...after configuring it as an infrastructure it has been working fine also.

    More Than Less, But Not All That., November 22, 2001
By picky shopper (Miami Lakes, FL USA)
I read the some of the mixed reviews, after I ordered mine, so I was more that a bit anxious waiting on the box. Boot and Setup went as advertised, and it was not until I tried the wireless that there were issues.

Like a lot of folks, I have found that the wireless is that, less. With the signal traveling 45 feet through three metal frame walls, I was getting a weak signal. A switch in the router settings (Advanced > Wireless > Antenna Selection) to Diversity Spread bumped the performance up. And let's face it, for web traffic, what's the big deal if my wireless LAN is only at 2MBS when my ADSL tops out at 1.5MBS?

My only big issue came with the update from Linksys. For two days I could not get into their site. And the teaser on the download page that this model supports Zone Alarm is not true.

You might not get it, but overall I am happy with the unit. It will never have a home on my corporate LAN, but here at home it does the trick.

    Works like a charm - knowing basic networking helps though, November 22, 2001
By unknown
Ended up buying this because of value proposition. Ended up getting the Linksys card to pair up with it. I would recommend upgrading the firmware right away. Mine came with one dated in June and after I upgraded it, I noticed that some of the settings I had previously configured had been lost. Also the DHCP IP that it is assigned by the cable co. had changed.
If one is aware of subnets and basic IP networking, it is pretty straightforward. I was somewhat disheartened by the fact that port forwarding requires the DHCP to be disabled.
The wireless component works fine, so far. I live in a high-rise so my perception of range is limited by physical constraints. I have not had any issues voiced by others on throughput but then again the max. range I have tested it is about 40 ft.
-> Bottom line - the mobility gained was worth it. The firmware is now fairly stable.


    Simply Amazing, November 22, 2001
By hssyed (Carmi, IL USA)
If you have cable/dsl/satellite, I highly recommend setting up a wireless network. Lie back in your easy chair with your laptop. Better yet, add a supefast wireless connection to another desktop computer in another room. No need to run wires through walls or carpet.

I have some friends that have purchased the same unit as well. Whats quite convenient is that we can bring our laptops to each other's apts and do online gaming...WIRELESSLY.

I purchased two of these units. One for home and one for school. The freedom to roam around with your laptop and have lightning fast speeds is truly amazing. If you have Windows XP, it autodetects everything. You do not even have to do any IP configuring (regardless of wireless or wired connections). In Windows 98 or Windows ME, you will need to stick in the IP address, which should take all of 30 seconds. Great product, easy to setup, and great data throughput. Its really hard to tell the difference in speed between when I'm surfing on my laptop with the wireless PCMCIA card or with it connected on one of the Router's LAN ports.

    So much for advertised specs, November 21, 2001
By dwv2 (Albany, NY USA)
I was very disappointed with this product. Put the router on the first machine and installed a wireless card on a PC in the basement. Everything was installed properly and there was no signal. Called technical support and was told that the signal could not go through the floor and a few walls.
I put the wireless card in a laptop and was able to get full 11Mbps transmission while in the same room as the router. As soon as I left the room, the signal degraded. Little or no reception less than 50 ft from router, and definately no signal in the basement, less than 100 ft away.
I truly do not recommend this product. Simply does not work as advertised. Great if you live in a small studio or one bedroom apartment, but in that case do you really need a wireless product.


    A piece of cake to install, November 19, 2001
By unknown
I have very limited knowledge of networking, but this was a piece of cake to set up. I installed one hardwired desktop and one laptop with a SMC wireless card. In ten minutes I was surfing the net thru my cable modem and printing wirelessly. I highly recommend this wireless router to anyone who wants to use their laptop in any room in the house or who just doesn't want to climb around in the attic running wires. The range isn't quite what they promised, but is totally adequete for any house under 3000 sq. ft.

    Do it yourself support!, November 14, 2001
By Nom de Plume (Pacific Northwest)
I've got mixed opinions about my Linksys BEFW11S4 Wireless 4-Port Cable/DSL Router. On one hand, I finally got it to work as advertised. On the other hand, I had to do it myself with no help from Linksys.

I read several positive and negative reviews here, but figured that most of the negative reviews were from people who didn't know an IP address from a CPU. Since I knew something about networking, I figured that I'd be able to breeze through installing and configuring this router to work with my cable modem with no problems. Wrong. Although I had configured the router correctly (I later discovered), the problem turned out to be defective firmware. I called Linksys technical support and, after several lengthy waits on hold, was only able to leave pleas for their technical support department to call me back (which they never did).

After no help from Linksys, I discovered another site that made reference to the exact problems I was experiencing. They mentioned the latest firmware that fixed this problem. I downloaded it from Linksys, installed it on the router, and the problems were largely fixed. Here's my list of problems that were fixed: IPSec Passthru Issues and 128 bit encryption. Bugs remaining to be fixed: occasional router lock-up requiring reset.

Now with IPSec Passthru fixed, I'm able to use the router as I intended. The wireless range is significantly less than I'd expected, but I'm looking for 3rd party antennas that can address this issue. Yes, it locks up sometimes, but it's easy to reset. I give it three stars - if they'd get better technical support, I'd give it four stars.

    Easy to install- READ FOR IPSEC PASSTHROUGH, November 11, 2001
By Jimmy Hat Night Filler (Ottawa)
I recently installed this unit for a client and it took around 2 hours. I am a consultant by day and found it relatively simple whereas I can speak for some of the users who may not have the experience and would hazard a guess at the difficulty of installing this product. Here's a hint- the Website says it supports ipsec passthrough. This allows VPN users to authenticate outside of the router to their work/provider. If you want this feature to work, do yourself a favour and upgrade the firmware.

And as for the consumers who have complaints on the range of the product, 3COM and Cisco products behave in the same manner. The key to installing a wireless product is to perform a site survey of the area you are installing the device. If you install it in a room with many walls and expect the RF signals to pass through them like laser beams think again. The best place to install this device is in a middle level (3 level house) in a high area, away from objects. Try it in different places and measure your signal strength using the utility that ships with the card. Follow these guidelines and you will succeed.

    Works Great For Me!, November 10, 2001
By K. Luke (San Diego, CA USA)
I am a computer systems engineer, and granted, though I may know a little more about networking than the average person, I still think that this Router is extrememely easy to set up. I am running my desktop wirelessly with a D-Link PCI card and my laptop with a Linksys PCMCIA card and have had no problems. The range is not astronomical, but for most people (like me), it still covers my whole house. I have two items of advice for anybody setting up their network with this router. In the properties of your wireless network card, set the Network Type to Infrastructure (took me a few minutes to figure this one out). Also, flash the firmware as soon as you possibly can. It seems that earlier versions of the flash were a little buggy, but it appears most of those problems have been fixed now (Including better WEP support).

    ok for me, November 7, 2001
By unknown
This router works well as a router. As a wireless access point, connection fails when the USB adapter is in a room, and the router is in another room perhaps 60 feet away with a right angle turn.

Also the USB adaptor does not work with windows XP, as suggested by their tech support. But I was able to get it to work, except that the utility window does not come up. They say the driver for XP will be available in a few days on their web site. I doubt it.

    decent for beginners....I guess, November 5, 2001
By Tony (Glendale, CA)
I finally got it working.....after 12 hours of fumbling around my computers. The tech support wasn't that great. I called them twice and got 2 different tech personnels who were hard to understand. One of them advised me to exchange the unit for a new one because we did not get it working the first time...and he assumed it was a lemon. Well...after my own personal internet research on networking, I figured this thing out somehow. And now it's finally functional. I have 2 computers hooked up with cables. I have yet to try the wireless option with my laptop.

Also, I think my personal firewall, Zone Alarm Pro is giving me problems. I might have to disable that. Oh well...more things to sort out.

    Works with Apple airport cards, November 4, 2001
By unknown
For those wondering, this Wireless Access Point works fine with Apple's airport card. Of course, since they all work with the Wi-Fi standard they should theoretically work. I wasn't able to read an confirmations on this so took a small leap of faith when I purchased this product (which I got for half of Apple's airport). I have the 128-bit WEP encryption enabled (I know it's not saying much for network security), but since Apple's airport card supports it I decided to enable it. I also purchased a Netgear PC wireless card for a PC laptop on the network and that also works fine with 128-bit enrcyption enabled. Installing and getting the Apple card to work was much easier then the Netgear card, but both work fine.

As for range, everyone's mileage will vary. But in my house I can go two floors up and still get respectable signal strength (around 50% to 60%). My house is tall and not very deep (3 livable floors). I've tested the range in all of the rooms and they appear to connect. But then again, there are no major steal beams or really solid walls/doors. Interestingly, as well, even if my laptop is right next to the access point, I can't get 100% signal strength, maybe 85% at the most.

The Access Point was pretty easy to get my DSL line (using PPPoE protocol) connected. So, all in all, I have had a good experience with this product (knock on wood), though I haven't had any reason to deal with tech support so far, so I can't comment on that aspect. I'm sure there are good and bad experiences with all products, and I thought I'd put my two cents on my positive experience with this product.

    This unit works great....if you live in a house w/no walls, November 3, 2001
By Bryce Leong (South San Francisco, Ca United States)
I was reading other responses of unsatisfied customers. I am glad I am not the only one who has problems with reception. I am currently logged onto the internet via my wireless router ...and I am getting 100% link, but 86% signal strength. Did I mention that I am a few inches away from the router! This unit works well if you have all your computers in 1 room...but if you have a house, FORGET IT! When I leave the room with my laptop I immediately get poor signal strength. I am fortunate that Fry's Electronics has a refund policy. I will return it this week.

    XP loves this one, November 1, 2001
By unknown
Connected my Samsung Cable Modem to it, connected it to my Dell 8100 3com integrated, sat down to struggle with XP and the router. Xp and the router had already worked it out, I was connected and done. It is configurable with your web browser but with my ISP, I didn't have to do anything.

Purchased two wireless USB network adapters, WUSB11, loaded the software in two other computers using Win98SE and attached the adapters. All Done. Internet, Printers and file sharing. Life is getting easier.

Page   23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50     of Total 50 Pages


Submit your review

Submit review form is only available to logged in users.

Summary (150 chars max)

Review

What is your location (for example: US, New Jersey)

Item Rating
1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars

Copyright 2001-2007 WiFiReview.com