WiFiReview.com
HOME  |  CONTACT US
Username Password Forgot password |  Register |  Logout
SMC Barricade g 2.4GHz 54Mbps Wireless Router with built in USB Printer Server
SMC Barricade g 2.4GHz 54Mbps Wireless Router with built in USB Printer Server
enlarge
Model: SMC2804WBRP-G
Brand: SMC
Manufacturer: SMC
Average Rating:    (submit your review here)
Total Reviews: 24
Form factor: External
Hardware platform: PC
Data link protocol: Ethernet, Fast Ethernet, IEEE 802.11b, IEEE 802.11g
 
Features:
Built-in USB Print Server
EZ 3-Click Installation Wizard
Universal Plug and Play support
Connects to a Cable/xDSL modem
Built-in Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI)
 
Description:
SMC2804WBRP-G -- The Barricade-g 2.4GHz 54Mbps Wireless Broadband Router is the first 802.11g Router to include a USB Print Server. With this router you can share a single printer among all the PCs connected to the Barricade via wired or wireless connection. This platform-independent device is the perfect networking solution for every home or business user looking for a simple, all-in-one network product. Virtual Private Network (VPN) pass-through support USB 1.1 Printer Port This 802.11g compliant device is up to 5 times faster than widely used 802.11b wireless LAN -- and backward compatible with existing 802.11b devices Supports Prism Nitro technology to extend your wireless range and optimize wireless throughput and performance Supports 802.1x authentication, Wi-Fi Protected Access ( WPA ), MAC address filtering & 64/128-bit Wired Equivalency Privacy ( WEP ) Allows connection at distances up to 1155 feet Compatible with PC, Mac & Linux; backed by 24/7 free technical support
 
User Reviews (24 total):
Page   1  2     of Total 2 Pages


    SMC2804WBRP-G a bummer, January 16, 2004
By ender2003 (Toronto, ON)
I can confirm what the other reviewer has said here, that the SMC2804WBRP-G *WILL* lose connection on your wireless client with annoying frequency, and that the ONLY way to bring it back is either a Reboot from the Browser Configuration Screen (or by unplugging it for a few seconds).

I had heard good things about SMC, but this product is simply not ready for primetime.

Also, unlike the other Reviewer, I had a tech support person say the OPPOSITE of the above, in that they were blaming the client for this problem. (NOTE: A word of warning about tech support - it is outsourced to India, and you stand a 50/50 chance of not being understood, but instead have recited back rote "answers". Very unsatisfying.

    Requires frequent rebooting, print server doesn't work, December 23, 2003
By Pen Name
I previously owned an SMC7004AWBR wireless router (802.11b w/ parallel print server) and was very happy with it. I upgraded to SMC's new version of this router, the SMC2804WBRP-G (802.11g w/ USB print server). I was very disappointed. I had to send it back and reinstall my old SMC7004AWBR router.

The SMC2804WBRP-G router has two major problems:
1) It regularly loses its wireless connection. The connection can only be restored by rebooting the router. The loss of connection has nothing to do with signal strength. The computer can be right next to the router and it still loses the connection. It's interesting that my old SMC7004AWBR had this exact same problem when I first installed it, which was later fixed by a firmware upgrade. So if SMC already had this problem with past routers, why did they release a new router with the same problem? Poor testing. I spent time with SMC tech support on this and they acknowledged the problem, but said there was no firmware upgrade yet available to fix this (there is an upgrade, but it doesn't fix this). I would definitely wait until they fix this problem before buying this router -- it then might be a great router. But right now it's a *really* frustrating problem that forces you to get up from your couch, walk to the room with the router, unplug the power cord from the router, count to 5 and plug it back in again. Repeat this on average every 30 min. (it might happen again in 5 min. or 1 hour, but it will definitely happen at least several times a night).

2) The USB print server does not work with the HP LaserJet 3330 printer. My old SMC7004AWBR router with a parallel print server worked perfectly with this printer. But this new router crashes every time I send a print job to it. Again, poor testing on SMC's part. Will this router work with your printer? Only trying it yourself will tell since SMC has not tested it with a range of printers and has not released a supported printer list -- their first customers are their testers.

I've now reinstalled my SMC7004AWBR and I continue to be happy with it -- it's rock solid. I guess I learned a lesson -- wait until SMC has a product out for six months or so before you buy.

BTW -- don't confuse this model with the similar 802.11g model without a print server (SMC2804WBR) -- that one uses the old-style case. It's getting good user reviews -- maybe it also uses older, more reliable firmware. Just watch out for this brand new model in the new case.

Bottom line: the SMC2804WBRP-G was released without thorough testing. Wait a few months until SMC processes the feedback from frustrated users like me and fixes the problems that currently make this router unusable.

One more note: You can tell this product is not ready for prime time when you go to the SMC web site and they still list it as "coming soon". There is no support information whatsoever, no driver downloads, no documentation, no acknowledgement of any kind that this product is shipping.

Page   1  2     of Total 2 Pages


Submit your review

Submit review form is only available to logged in users.

Summary (150 chars max)

Review

What is your location (for example: US, New Jersey)

Item Rating
1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars

Copyright 2001-2007 WiFiReview.com