WiFiReview.com
HOME  |  CONTACT US
Username Password Forgot password |  Register |  Logout
SMC7004AWBR Barricade Cable/DSL router w/ 3-port 10/100Mbps, Print Server, and 802.11b 11Mbps Access Point
SMC7004AWBR Barricade Cable/DSL router w/ 3-port 10/100Mbps, Print Server, and  802.11b 11Mbps Access Point
enlarge
Model: SMC7004AWBR
Brand: SMC
Manufacturer: SMC
Average Rating:    (submit your review here)
Total Reviews: 247
Platforms: Windows NT, Macintosh, Windows 98, Windows 2000, Windows NT 3.5, Windows NT 4, Windows NT 5, PowerMac, Windows Me, Windows XP, Windows 2000 Server, Mac OS X, Mac OS 9 and below, Windows
Form factor: External
Hardware platform: PC
Data link protocol: Ethernet, Fast Ethernet
 
Features:
Built-in NAT firewall security
Wireless operation at 11, 5.5, 2, or 1 Mbps
Connects to a cable/xDSL modem, dial-up modem, or Ethernet backbone
All-in-one solution provides switching, IP sharing, print server, and firewall security
Platform independent--works with PC or Mac
 
Description:
The Barricade wireless broadband router is the ideal networking solution for home and small business users alike, providing the ultimate in mobility with its wireless operation. The platform-independent multi-functional router is combined with a 3-port 10/100 Mbps dual-speed switch and incorporates both a built-in print server and firewall security against hackers and other intruders.
 
User Reviews (247 total):
Page   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12     of Total 12 Pages


    unknowledgeable customer service bad manual, February 4, 2002
By Luan C. Do (Vienna, VA United States)
For [price], after rebate, this is a great unit, if you don't have to deal with unknowleageable tech support.

During installation, if you have already installed DSL on your first computer, you must establish connection to the 7004AWBR box (hereafter the box) with a second computer or remove PPPoe from the first computer.

The manual assumes that you have not installed DSL software (i.e. PPPoe) on the computer that you use to gain access to the box's loggin menu. Note that typing ... on your web brower should connect your computer to the box, unless you have PPPoe installed on your computer.

In my case, I first had to install Verizon's DSL on my first computer so that I can register and get a user ID and password, which are to be provided to the box. Therefore,using the first computer with Verizon DSL installed, I kept running into the choice of logging onto Verizon or working off-line when I typed ... to connect to the box. Finally, my brother helped out by connecting his laptop (i.e. the second computer) to the box and was able to gain access to the box's login menu.

Before figuring out what the problem was with the help of my brother, I had to wait for 1hr 15 min. for tech support who could only tell me to reset the box several times and that the product was probably defective and offered to send me a new unit. The tech never asked if DSL (PPPoe) was installed or not.

I hope this helps.

    I love it, February 2, 2002
By Keith (New Hope, PA)
Set up and configuration were very easy, but I did have a Linkssys router before, so I knew what I was doing. Connection on my DSL line with PPPoE works great.
Wireless setup was also a snap, but then again, in doing the research I knew what to do. I have only one PC about 10 feet away connected, but no problems. We'll see once I have the wireless card for my handheld, how it works with didtance.
Printer set up was also easy, I have a Microsoft Host and a Linux host both using the shared printer.
I agree with the other reviewers that the documentation is not enough for people who have never done this before.
I also have sent email to SMC support to ask about the Intel Video phone, but so far no response.

I recommend it, but not if you have no knowledge on what you are doing.

    Terrible support, January 30, 2002
By unknown
First of all let me say how excited I was to spend over 300 dollars on this equipment and set up a home network. Then I had a few problems installing it and called their tech support last night.

After 50 minutes on hold I reached someone and was assisted. When I asked why do they keep customers on hold for almost an hour I was told that they had 15 support techs on at night and that was plenty. I guess its plenty if you want to spend an hour on your day waiting for the privilege of talking with one.

The problem was easily resolved. If thy had added two lines in the manual from the box it would have saved me an hour. So I get the Barricade talking with the computer but not with my DSL provider. Back on hold with you for another 45 minutes when a rude man comes on and says he was not technical support but would take a message to have someone call me back. He said the hold times were too long and he was asked to clear these calls. When I asked when someone would call me back (its already 10:30 p.m.) he asked me if I wanted to the weekend or at night. I asked are they scheduling appointments and he said it was a range of six hours. I was shocked, you mean I get to buy product and when I have problems they will treat me like an appliance delivery?? They will call me between 6-12 at night or sometime during the weekend when its convenient for them?? When I questioned him on this he started to schedule me without my agreement, when I asked him to stop he said he would have to hang up on me. As I said can I speak to your supervisor I heard click!

Well I am returning the product to buy a competitors.

By the way I a CIO for a large company and get asked for referrals from my colleagues on this kind of equipment all the time, you will not be on the list!

    just stops working..., January 29, 2002
By chrisfranklin (Atlanta, GA)
Short and sweet:

the good:
- easy setup with Windows XP
- excellent range (strong signal two rooms/60 feet away)

the bad:
- stops working with no warning; have to reboot often (still hit or miss after rebooting)
- runs very hot (may be the cause of the problems)
- tech support is generally responsive but not very helpful

THE BOTTOM LINE: Don't buy this router, especially if you depend on your internet connection for work. Other reviews (put up after I bought mine) mention the exact same problem. The router worked very well when working, but gets 1 star because I don't think it's too much to ask that a product work all the time.

    Works great as a router, not so good as a print server, January 28, 2002
By unknown
I've been using this for the past 2 weeks as a wired and wireless router connected to cable modem and I've been more than satisfied with its performance in that regard. I previously had used a wired router (SMC 7004BR) without ever trying out the print server feature. I decided to go with this wireless/wired router so that we could use a laptop from all points in the house. I haven't tried it out from outside the house but in the house it works from all points, through walls at distances up to 60 feet (small house, centrally located router). Setup was as easy as it was with the 7004BR and I was up and on the net in no time. But I'm knocking a couple of stars off because I really hoped to use the print server feature to print from the laptop but it doesn't even print from the wired PCs to either my Lexmark Z11 or Z42. I updated everything (firmware, printer drivers, router printer port monitor) but it still doesn't work. Tech support, although 24/7 and toll-free, was a major disappointment. After waiting close to 30 minutes, the SMC tech guy ran me through a few unsuccessful suggestions that I had already gleamed from their website FAQs, then finally suggested that I use the Windows Networking client instead to set up one of the computers as a server. From what I've read on various forums this seems to be a fairly common problem/complaint with the print server feature. Otherwise it is a good product. I thought the print server feature was a bonus when I bought the 7004BR for $50. I got both the 7004AWBR and a SMC wireless PCMCIA card for about $200 after rebates, which was a pretty good deal, but I really wanted the print server to work.

    Overall, not bad, January 25, 2002
By unknown
Selected this product because it was a good deal, and had decent customer reviews compared to competing products.

Overall I am happy, but I do have similar problems to those discussed by other reviewers:
1. First and foremost, the documentation (is poor)! This wasnt a problem for me as I am fairly savvy with hardware installation and system admin tasks--but I would think twice about buying any SMC products again. Havent tried their phone support, but have no doubt that it is on par with printed doc.
2. Had a little trouble getting setup--could never figure out why--just reset a few times and it started working great.
3. Occasionally (about once per week), the wireless (not LAN) connection drops, and like other reviewers, I have to eject my card (also SMC), and reinsert. Perhaps this is fairly common for all wireless routers/cards.
4. The WLAN light, which I think the documentation says is supposed to indicate wireless activity, stopped all blinking within a few hours of setup, and seems to be dead. No big whoop.

On the plus side:
1. I get good transmission speeds (at or near 1.5Mbps limit of cable modem) from everywhere in the house (including upstairs and basement), even though there are walls/floors, large appliances, cordless phones (900MHz, not 2.1GHz), etc. in between). Cant say anything about transmission at higher speeds (up to 11Mbps limit) as Im not yet doing any peer-to-peer on the house LAN.2. Despite poor documentation, setup and config is rather easy (though I may have just been lucky) with default settings. Now using it with two other systems in the house, to share cable modem and printer.
3. Ive only had to reboot the router twice in two months of use, and those were due to problems with the cable modem service.

In summary: Decent product, with significant room for improvement. Not entirely confident that it wont be problematic in the future--but I suspect that is the case with wireless in general, not necessarily this product.

    works great but for three minor issues, January 21, 2002
By unknown
Read the reviews and picked the barricade over the linksys and d-link based on reviews. I am pleased with my choice Device worked plug-n-play and was up inside of 20 minutes on a Win2000 laptop. I am a corporate technology user and make extensive use of VPN, remote networking, X-windows, and other similar types of applications. The barricade has worked flawlessly enabling me to telecommute from home.

Only three complaints:
1. Have been unable to get the printer server to work when connected wirelessly. Seems to work fine when hardwired to the build-in hub, but wireless just sends garbage to the printer. Had to go hardwire the printer to my laptop before I bought the Barricade, so I am no worse off than I was before. I view this as an inconvenince as the print server was a "nice to have" instead of a decision factor in buying it. Have not pushed this issue with SMC yet, so I am unable to know how responsive they are.

2. Unable to get very old Win95 laptop (133 MHz Pentium) to work with the SMC wireless card. Am limited to using that computer hardwired - which is not a major issue for me given that I use that PC in only one location - and I was able to locate the router there so a hardwired connection is fine. Appears to be a driver issue getting the drivers installed correctly. Have not pushed this issue with SMC yet, so I am unable to know how responsive they are.

3. About once every 2 hours, the wireless card loses connection with the router. Unable to determine why, but could possibly be because of a neighbor with a 2.4 GHz phone getting a call or other interference. When this happens, I have to eject the wireless card from the PCMCIA slot and re-insert to reestablish connection. Not a big deal in theory, but given that I use remote desktop software for work, disconnecting the card means disconnecting the remote desktop session at a sometime inopportune time. Currently just living with it.

    Happy Camper, January 21, 2002
By unknown
I am very please with my purchased of Linksys BEFW11S4 wireless 4-Port Cable/DSL and SMC Network SMC2632W WIRELESS Network PC. This product is great and so easy to install.I love it. It is so conviennience to cary my Laptop to work around my house.

    Customer Service Stinks, January 14, 2002
By unknown
I am writing this review while I am on hold for SMC technical support. So far I have been on hold for 45 minutes. This product was supposed to be easy to set up. Wrong. I have tried everything to get this thing to work. The WAN link cannot obtain an IP address from my service provider (Comcast). By the way, still on hold.

    Happy Camper, January 14, 2002
By Joe (San Francisco Bay Area)
With a lot of mixed reviews about all vendor's wireless routers and PCI cards I decided to chance it and go with SMC. I bought the SMC7004AWBR router and SMC2632W PCMCIA card. Primary descision was based upon additional 4 wired ports and 1 printer port on the router plus the support for Windows XP.

The router installed in under 5 minutes (I stuck mostly with defaults). It took me longer to move the printer cable from the PC (XP) to the router then it took to install and configure. A complete novice might get caught up in some of the terminology found in the instruction for router setup (doc & screen).

Feeling lucky I installed the wireless card into my Laptop (Win 2k) and after going through the 30 second driver install I was surfing the web.

Now some reviews I've read indicated that these devices did not support VPN but I can tell you I was connected to my office within a minute. Of course you need to know your settings.

Right now I'm about 40 feet from my router completely untethered, with my feet up and composing this review. Speed has not been measured but browser painted pretty quickly.

For anyone considering, there is no gaurantee you'll have the same luck. Environment and your knowledge of PCs will factor into your experience. The only suggestion I'd make is stick with the same vendor for both ends. If you run into connectivity problem, you'll avoid finger pointing with Technical Support.

Well I'm off to try the Print Server using wirelss connection.

    Extremely Poor Product Support & Documentation, January 13, 2002
By y_me_techie (Illinois)
The reviews I read here are what convinced me to purchase this product. I wanted a wireless network for our home computers (we have a system with 4 computers). I recently moved to a new home and decided I didn't want to run cable. I had a lot of problems getting the network set up properly. After hours and hours of being on hold and working with support, they finally blamed my ISP. My ISP stated they wouldn't support us because they don't support more than 1 connection. We finally determined that we were having some problems with our ISP, however, we also were having problems with the wireless system. It would come up for a few minutes and then I'd lose it. After hours of being on hold and working with support, yet AGAIN, I finally hired someone to come in and help me troubleshoot. He went through some settings with me - SETTINGS WHICH WERE NOT COVERED IN THE PRODUCTION SET UP DOCUMENTATION - and which their technical support also did not have enough sense to go through with me (I'm just a regular user, how am I supposed to know what to set if they don't tell me?). We finally had it up and running in no time. The connection quality is not as good as we would like for the laptops when they are not on the same floor. It gets really poor on the 3rd floor of the house, but at least we can still access the internet. We do have to reboot the router at least every few days or so for it to work properly. I would be sure to have someone who really knows and understand networks and their dynamics to help you before buying this. I would also be prepared for very poor support. I'm still waiting - over a week now - for documentation to get the print server portion of this running properly for 2 of our systems on Windows 2000.

    It works but range can be an issue, January 12, 2002
By RK (San Clemente, CA USA)
I replaced my phone line network in my house with this router and wireless cards from SMC for the laptops. It took me a few tries to get it all working but finally it worked. It seems to work about as fast as my phoneline network did. It added the convenience of being able to roam around the house, but I am limited as to where i can go. I have yet to experiment with moving the router around physically. I need to buy a longer RJ-45 cable to do this. However, I will be limited there because i want to use the device as a print server also, so the parallel cable will limit how much i can move it around to get better range. Things would probably work better in the house if i could put the unit more towards the middle of the house instead of where it is now, downstairs at the front of the house.

Nevertheless, the unit works well when you even have a poor quality link. The speed is quick. However, if the link becomes too poor then you can lose it all together and you have to use the configuration utility to rescan to get the thing to link again.

Anyway i accomplished my objective that both my wife and i can surf the internet on our laptops and the kids can use the internet on the desktop in the study. We are not restricted to plugging into a phone line outlet, but we are restricted by the range. Not perfect, but a good compromise. The new standard 802.11a coming out will probably solve the range issue, but it will be much more expensive at first.

My final word is that I would recommend the unit, but placement of the router is an important variable in the range you will get indoors.

    a worthless piece of metal, January 4, 2002
By unknown
All I have to say about this product is that the money you spent will be money not well spent. I returned the product due to its' inefficient range, poor setup support, and overwhelmingly false claims with the product in its advertisement. If you want to waste your money on this, go ahead. But you've been warned!

    The best and the most stable home network router, January 3, 2002
By Porsche Carrera GT (CT) (South West Connecticut (USA))
I did alot of research on a new Wireless router and after reading all conflicting reviews for the same product from several leading sites you are totally confused. You find people that love the product or they want to throw out of the window.

I LOVE THIS PRODUCT - I bought the SMC router, the SMC wireless USB and the SMC wireless laptop card so now I have three computers all connected to the same cable modem all on Windows ME. You read about poor reception - well let me tell you - I have 3500 sq feet house on 3 levels with the router on the ground floor on one side of the house and I can roam around the house from the basement to the 2nd floor and outside with good to decent signal. For a trial I was streaming a video from a web site at 300kbps to the laptop and I moved everywhere, even outside (at 19 degree...freezing) and I never lost signal or switched to lower bandwith.

You read about people having difficulties and having to reset the router many times - never happened to me. Since the day I received and installed this router and the two wireless cards, I never had to reset anything. My advise: If the router work just fine when you first install you don't need to upgrade to the latest firmware release just to be on the latest (this is called bloody edge technology not leading edge technology)

I thought that was difficult to install the set. very simple - If you are using OptimumOnline cable modem just power off your computer, power off the cable modem for about 2 minutes, connect the network cables and power on everything -You are now up and running. For the wireless cards - Install the card or the USB cable, power on your computer and install the software (do not change configuration) - after 2 minutes (time to start your computer and install the small SMC software you have a home wireless network.

I currentely use my Pentium 4 Dell 8100 as a server and the other two PC as clients transfering amongst the three PC several mb of data.

Highly recomend the SMC router and the SMC USB card.

    Plug and Play Networking, January 2, 2002
By Valtech (Addison, TX United States)
Before I purchased this router, I read a number of reviews about the various products (SMC, Linksys, D-Link et al) and SMC always rated high with lots of features. I've also heard of problems with some wireless routers and 2.4Ghz phones but not with the SMC equipment. The good news is that is extremely easy to network and for that reason I highly recommend it. I have had a few problems accessing the admin program from my laptop which is directly connected to the router. However, a firmware upgrade and a reboot seemed to have corrected it. I have contacted SMC technical support and they are surprisingly fast to respond to enquiries. I've only received bad advice on one occasion from someone who wanted me to replace everything except the kitchen sink when trying to fix the problem of connecting to the router admin program via my laptop.

My home network is composed of Win98, W2K Sever, XP-Prof, Linux, and Solaris for intel and all network without a problem using the router.

One thing you might want to consider is that it's not a 4 port Ethernet connection but a 3 port Ethernet connection and 1 printer port. Not that you buy these things because you want a lot of Ethernet ports but SMC does give you the impression that it is 4 Ethernet ports.

    buy it!, December 28, 2001
By jimsladester (Mountain View, CA United States)
I have had the 7004awbr with their wireless PC card for 3 months now. It was *very* easy to set up and works great. I ran it with winNT on my desktop and win98 on my laptop, and now have win2000 on both desktop and laptop. The desktop is connected by cable and the laptop wireless. I have nothing but good things to say about it. Fast connection downstairs, out in my backyard. Print server works great. I even recently went to my brother's house, he has a linksys wireless router, and my SMC pc card let me on his wireles network NO PROBLEM.

I bought it for ~160 and the PC card for ~80. Great deal on a product that works as advertised w/ no hicups.

    DOES NOT WORK WELL WITH VPN AND NETMEETING., December 27, 2001
By unknown
This is an excellent router as a basic wireless access point. But you are going to loose some functionality: VPN and Microsoft NetMeeting. Even if you set your computer's IP address as DMZ, the VPN and Microsoft NetMeeting does not work consistently through this router. So be careful if you plan to use any of the above. The Linksys router that our IT department uses works perfectly. So I bought this router but can not connect to work through VPN (SonicWall). Makes it pretty useless for me.

Plus the tech support takes hours to answer the phone, plus they are not much help. All they say is to set up your computer as DMZ. This is supposed to wide open all the ports, NOT...

    modem not included, December 27, 2001
By unknown
This seems to be a great wireless router with several features. The documentation is sparse, but anyone with experience can easily navigate the setup screens, which can even be accessed from a wireless connection. Unfortunately, a modem is *not* included for dialup capabilities---if there is no DSL/cable available, an external modem must be purchased separately and attached to the included serial port.

    Sorta works, December 26, 2001
By Christopher T. Chan (San Jose, CA)
I've had the same problems that others have already mentioned. Good product and router except:

1) Problems transferring large files over wireless. The router hangs and needs to be "rebooted" or powered off, and back on to reset and work again.

2) Had problems recognizing IP using Dynamic IP, had to use Static setting, after upgrading firmware & reseting to factory, this finally worked.

Pros:
1) Has built-in DNS which I've seen others don't quite do within the local network.

2) Easy we-interface to configuration.

3) Built-in print server.

4) Great range and reception from my entire home.

Overall, I really wanted this product to work, but eventually returned it b/c of the file transfer problem. I got a D-Link instead and have had no major probs with that.

    Wonderful product at great price, December 22, 2001
By jungleebee (RI United States)
It is very easy to set up the whole wirless network using the SMC wireless router. The instruction is minimal, but it is not that difficult to figure it out. I have it set up with 2 PCs laptops and a Mac. Now I could roam around the house (basement, kitchen, etc.) getting wireless broadband connections, it is truly a dream. I highly recommend the Orinoco gold card, the connection is wonderful working with this router. This is the first time I try to set up a network in my house, and it couldn't be better than this.

Page   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12     of Total 12 Pages


Submit your review

Submit review form is only available to logged in users.

Summary (150 chars max)

Review

What is your location (for example: US, New Jersey)

Item Rating
1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars

Copyright 2001-2007 WiFiReview.com