WiFiReview.com
HOME  |  CONTACT US
Username Password Forgot password |  Register |  Logout
SMC7004AWBR Barricade Cable/DSL router w/ 3-port 10/100Mbps, Print Server, and 802.11b 11Mbps Access Point
SMC7004AWBR Barricade Cable/DSL router w/ 3-port 10/100Mbps, Print Server, and  802.11b 11Mbps Access Point
enlarge
Model: SMC7004AWBR
Brand: SMC
Manufacturer: SMC
Average Rating:    (submit your review here)
Total Reviews: 247
Platforms: Windows NT, Macintosh, Windows 98, Windows 2000, Windows NT 3.5, Windows NT 4, Windows NT 5, PowerMac, Windows Me, Windows XP, Windows 2000 Server, Mac OS X, Mac OS 9 and below, Windows
Form factor: External
Hardware platform: PC
Data link protocol: Ethernet, Fast Ethernet
 
Features:
Built-in NAT firewall security
Wireless operation at 11, 5.5, 2, or 1 Mbps
Connects to a cable/xDSL modem, dial-up modem, or Ethernet backbone
All-in-one solution provides switching, IP sharing, print server, and firewall security
Platform independent--works with PC or Mac
 
Description:
The Barricade wireless broadband router is the ideal networking solution for home and small business users alike, providing the ultimate in mobility with its wireless operation. The platform-independent multi-functional router is combined with a 3-port 10/100 Mbps dual-speed switch and incorporates both a built-in print server and firewall security against hackers and other intruders.
 
User Reviews (247 total):
Page   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12     of Total 12 Pages


    Very, very, very Good Stuff!!, December 20, 2001
By V. Rodriguez (Bronx, NY United States)
Well, the unit was easy to setup; I encountered no problems. I connected my Verizon Online DSL modem to the WAN port with minimum effort. The desktop I used automaticly received an IP address and all i had to do was access the internal web page to configure the settings. I configured the DSL Section to connect using id and password and tested it with my desktop. It connected to the internet right away.

I installed a smc wireless card to my laptop and the same thing, i was up and running with no problem. The Wireless hub has good range and so far everything is perfect. I really recomend this product over Linksys, Dlink and netgear hands down. The price is decent and it's worth it. Trust me you gonna like it.

    Maybe mine was faulty..., December 19, 2001
By Brian Brown (Longmont, CO USA)
The Barricade and D-Link's 713-P are essentially the same hardware, with different firmware and printer driver support provided by their respective companies. My Barricade had some issues, so I sent it back for the 713-P, which for me has worked flawlessly. I have read that quality control for both units is pretty low, which explains the polarity of reviews here on both products. (...) though, whatdya expect? These things contain a full-bandwith three-port switch, a wireless access point, an Internet router, AND a print server. Buying these separately might set you back (..).

Here's a mini-review of my Barricade.

The pros:
Brain-dead simple to install

Nice list of features

Pretty good firmware support from the manuf.

Flexible setups for DSL, cable, and dial-up accounts

Very nice MAC address association/ connection support

Very good range and speeds (for me)... well over 4 Mbit/s all over my house and out in the yard

Fast and easy print driver setup (easier & better than DLink's)

The cons (for me):
Periodic drops of TCP/IP connection (no pings, no Internet... dead), requiring unit reboots or waiting for it to come back online

The unit would clearly not pass through the NetBEUI protocol to my wired clients, so I was stuck with no safe way to connect to other computers via Windows File and Printer sharing (you should never, never let your network adapters communicate through TCP/IP for this... unbind TCP/IP or you WILL be hacked!)

So, like I said, I sent it back. I could have tried my luck with another unit, but I went with the D-Link to check it out. With a functioning unit, it would be a toss-up for me which to choose... the Barricade has better printer support, the D-Link has slightly better Throughput and a cleaner Web-based interface.

Hope this helps,
Brian Brown

    Simple effective wireless solution, December 19, 2001
By unknown
I recently purchased the wireless barricade after reading reviewsfor Linksys and other devices. I chose the barricade due to the number of positive reviews and the fact that SMC had addressed windows XP issues. After checking wireless networking websites I went with the orinoco gold card for my dell inspiron8100 running windows XP.
Very simple install Just read directions runs well set up the barricade with a Win98 desktop. Had some difficulty after updating the firmware, just had to shut everything off. Good tech support after long hold time (ten minutes). Then, installed orinoco software, went to orinoco site and downloaded winxp drivers via dialup. Then plugged in the pci card and winxp identified the card and set it up in the background.

Concerns have not been valid. The barricade runs no hotter than my dsl modem. Distance is great. I live in a large old house with plaster/lathe walls. I walk greater than 50 feet with no trouble. I am upstairs now and my router is downstairs in back corner of house.
Couldn't be sweeter. I recommend these products.
P.S. Another plus of the barricade is that you get a printer port and 3 hard ports.

    SMC wireless router & WEP with non-Apple hardware, December 13, 2001
By Jarrod (Denver, CO)
Here are a few tips using the SMC Barricade SMC7004AWBR wireless router and WEP. I have a pre-Airport and pre-G3 Powerbook and an iMac SE. I wanted an alternative (read cheaper) solution than Apple's Airport Base Station.

The iMac came with an Airport card pre-installed and has since been upgraded to Airport 2 in OS X. I also recently acquired a Lucent Technologies Orinoco (formerly Wavelan) Silver PC Card from Agere Systems, which offers 64-bit WEP for my Powerbook.

The most challenging aspect of setting up the WEP security is getting it to work on each hardware device. I'll explain the three steps it will take to get the above configurations working. We're still using Macs, so it's relatively painless once you know how. The steps below assumes you're familiar with the wireless aspects of your hardware and that you're not yet using or haven't figured out how to enable WEP using your SMC router.

Step 1 for the router: Access your SMC router via your web browser on any Mac using a hardwire Ethernet connection and click on the last link in the left pane, "Wireless". In the main window, under Wireless Setting, select a name for your wireless router in the space next to Network ID(SSID). The next item, Channel, can be left alone. The item after that is where you set your WEP Security. In my case, since the PC Card in my Powerbook uses 64-bit WEP encryption, I chose the "Enable IEEE 64 bit Shared Key security" option for the router. Now choose "WEP Key 1" and enter a Hexadecimal string of 10 characters (you can only use the numbers 0-9 and the letters a-f). I try to come up with a nifty pass phrase to help me remember the string, which may prove challenging using hex. In our example, let's use decade2010. Save your changes and reboot the router.

Step 2 for the iMac: In either OS 9 or X, invoke the Airport Setup Assistant. The assistant should detect your SMC wireless router now. In OS X, you'll get an Enter Network Password dialog box where you'll need to enter the hexadecimal string you came up with in Step 1. But in order for it to work, you have to enter a dollar sign ($) before the string. In our example, the network password that will work with your Apple branded Airport card and the SMC router is: $decade2010

Step 3 for the Powerbook: Open the ORiNOCO control panel and click on the Encryption tab. Click on the Enable Encryption check box and next to Key 1: enter a zero (0) and the letter "x" before the string in Step 1. This lets the Wavelan card know you'll be transmitting using a hexadecimal string. In our example, Key 1 will look like this: 0xdecade2010 (don't forget to set the "Transmit using" to use Key 1 and then click on Set to save your changes). If you click back to the Basic tab, you should see Closed Network for Network:, and your router's name for Net Name: which you set up in Step 1.

This setup works flawlessly for me and I highly recommend this non-Apple branded hardware.

The SMC wireless router has a printer server port and a serial port if you want to add your old 56K modem to it. This is good if you have broadband and it goes down. I've only tested this scenario and I pray to the Wireless Goddess that I never need to invoke it! It also bridges AppleTalk, which is awesome for printing to old laser printers that have Ethernet, but don't support TCP/IP and for easy file sharing. The USB Printer Sharing in OS 9 works great too.

The Lucent wireless PC Card is actually an Apple Airport card, but Lucent of course adds the antenna. This card is compatible with any Powerbook with a PCMCIA slot in it (even the 5300 and 190 series!) using Mac OS 7.5.2 and greater.

And best of all, SMC and Lucent support Mac users while many other non-Apple wireless hardware vendors do not.

Have fun in the wireless zone!

- Jarrod

    Works great., December 13, 2001
By John Mitchell (Richmond, VA)
I use it every day. The only problem I have is that it makes my 2.4 gigahertz wireless phone pop a little, when I am close to the wireless router. I cant blame the wireless router, all of them work on the same frequncey as my phone. I have not used the print server feature yet, so I cant comment on that. But the wired part of the router, and the wireless part, work perfectly. Easy to set up too. At least it was for me. Cloning itself to your mac address was a very important feature. I use this wireless router with a cable modem.

    the best and easy..., December 13, 2001
By Viengkham Lasaath (San Diego, CA United States)
i got this router up and running less than 5 minutes. Not only that its the best, the distance is very good too. Right now im sharing cable connection from my friend across the street from my house. The signal is running through "3" solid cement walls and "2" sound proof walls. The router is placed on his window and my usb wireless from SMC is in my room. GUESS WHAT!! IM GETTING FULL CONNECTION FROM ABOUT 75-100ft away from the router!!! 5 walls still working fine @ 11mbs. I rate the router and the wireless usb 6 stars!!! good distance!!!

    works for non techie, December 11, 2001
By unknown
Its not perfect but its a very good solution for someone who doesn't want to run cables or hire someone else to set up a home network. Documentation is sparce but it only took me (non techie) 20 minutes to get it up and running with my cable modem. Very satisfied with performance of print server and network functions.

    Great product, December 9, 2001
By unknown
I received the SMC wireless router and print server last weekend, hooked it up to my cable modem and to my Brother printer, attached it by ethernet wire to my desktop computer, and plugged the SMC wireless card into my laptop. After 20 minutes of configuring and 10 minutes on the phone with the helpful SMC support people, it works perfectly. This was a huge surprise for me, because I am a computer knucklehead. I work on the web on my laptop now in the kitchen and in the living room, and the connection is fast and great, even through many walls and ceilings. The print server works great too. It is really liberating to be able to do computer things where you want, rather than tethered to the wall. A great product all around.

    Great router, especially for the price, December 8, 2001
By Mike Paradis (Goshen, KY USA)
In terms of what it offers for its price, this router cannot be beat. MAC Address Control, a built-in firewall, web-based configuration, and many other features make this router easy to set up and get running. As with all wireless products, don't expect your range to be too far and go through any more than 5 or 6 walls. Besides that, it has worked very well with PCs and Macs. The only problem I had was setting it up to do PPPoE for a DSL login, but that just took a little bit of extra work. Also... on really neat feature is its ability to clone the MAC address of the computer with which you are setting it up, so if your ISP does MAC control you won't have to call them up and wait on hold forever to get them to allow a new MAC address on. Just another little feature that makes this an overall great product.

    Think Twice, December 8, 2001
By unknown
If you want to buy SMC products, think twice:

1. Their technical support never returned my email question.
2. Their customer service returned my email question with an auto-reply message.
3. When I bought this product, it has a rebate. But see what I got: I received the rebate cheque just one day before the cheque is void! They were lucky as I couldn't go to a bank to cash in the cheque on the EXIPRY date.

All the above are TRUTH.

If you still want to buy this product, I can tell you as a matter of fact, I bought two of these. One for my home, and one for my company's branch office. The product is easy to setup and is still working.

    A solid machine that resolves many problems...., December 7, 2001
By dowadiddi (Weston, FL United States)
I first saw the SMC wireless in action when visiting my colle student kids and I was blown away from point one.

The wireless connections are iron clad and it certainly helped me plug in my sony vaio to a broadband connection to play on the internet at 7 AM while the rest of the house slept. (of course they are students after all)

When I got back home I bouhgt the straight wireless SMC network (not this model its only the wireless networ) and I was bummed out because I had a lot of problems getting connections. I sold that sucker (...) and bought this little baby with the router and the print server.

Now I had no need for my network computer, we are all running Windows 2000, and from the moment that it was up and running I never looked back. BTW I called SMC tech support sveral times because of questions regarding the super security systems etc that this sytem has,and, i want to tell you that tech support was FABULOUS .... that in itself today is worth the price of the product ..

Lastly one incredible benefit of this sytem is that it has a true peer to peer network capablilties.... WOW ....

This is one of the geatest innovations for the small network user ever made ......

    Worst product ever, December 5, 2001
By marcsmole (NY, NY United States)
I seriously think there is something wrong with the latest generation of broadband routers by SMC. I bought the 7004AWBR router, and it's been crashing on me every single day disconnecting from the Internet. I can't ping the router, or access the admin web page to reset it. It's extremely frustrating having to manually reset the router everyday. SMC tech support has been unresponsive to this matter. Btw, I upgraded the firmware of the router the same day I installed it. I also had a 7004ABR as well before, and that kept on crashing on me. So I'd suggest you all stay away from SMC broadband routers, unless you want to reset the router everyday.

    Good stuff!, December 2, 2001
By Mark Guzowski (Idaho Falls, Idaho USA)
This is one of the neatest products I've added to my 'computer setup' recently. Everything works like a champ. I had no problems whatsoever configuring the wireless connection, the wired connections, the print server, the dhcp server, etc. It works whether my win2k domain server is up or not. If you want to share an internet connection, and/or break into wireless, this product (or one's like it) are hard to beat!

Although the 7004AWBR doesn't have a stateful firewall, it did seem to do quite well when some serious abuse was launched at it. And, this product integrates beautifully with a Cisco PIX 501 (which is a stateful firewall). Note that XP also comes with a stateful firewall built in.

Just remember that unless configured carefully, wireless access can provide an easy gateway for would-be hackers. At minimum use mac address control, and at best use IPSec/Kerberos also (the former is easy to do, and the latter is definitely more work).

    Complex configuration, 18 month lifespan, December 2, 2001
By John G Faughnan (www.faughnan.com) (St. Paul, MN USA)
[Update: June 2003. By May of 2003 the wireless portion of this device was failing. I had to reset the Barricade about every 3-10 days. At least one other person reports a similar experience after 2 years of use. I got about 18 months of use.

I don't know that the competition is much better. I suspect to get a robustly build device that generates RF you may need to pay quite a bit more, perhaps on an Apple AirPort or a Cisco WAP.

For what it's worth the Barricade supported PC and Mac clients for about 18 months with good performance. Documentation in later versions of this device was much better.]

The multi-function device includes:

- router/firewall (NAT)
3 ports and a WAN port (in my case the "WAN" is really my existing fixed LAN, see below).

- a PC print server. Requires installing software on Win2K machines, OS X has some support. Setup in OS X is tricky. Search usenet for my postings on that.

- wireless access point (WAP)

This is a more complex device than the BreezeCom BreezeNet I used to have. The BreezeCom was a bridge, it didn't even have a network address. It acted like a hub and was transparent; I configured the wireless client just as I would a wired device on my LAN.

It would be better if the SMC device were firewall protecting my LAN from intrustion from an unauthorized wireless client (see 802.11b Security Issues), but as a device installed into my wired LAN it's "pointing" the wrong way. The SMC WAP is already working inside my LAN, so the firewall is "protecting" the wireless laptop against the machines on my regular LAN. In fact the real threat is unauthorized wireless client access to my wired LAN machines.

Physically it's unobtrusive, the antennae need to be oriented vertically. It comes with a large "power brick" transformer; I wish they'd charge $2.00 more and get a transformer that's easier to plug in to a crowded UPS.

Installation

I downloaded and installed the painless ROM upgrade. Router configuration is by web browser, there's no other access. For initial configuration I plugged one machine directly into the router and changed the network settings as per the manual. For some reason the DHCP function didn't work, but I didn't spend any time on it. I just gave my desktop machine an IP address of 192.168.123.100, subnet 255.255.255.0 and set the gateway to the router 198.168.123.254. Once I had upgraded the router and had control of it I changed it to have an "external" address of 10.0.0.200 so it would be visible on my LAN with a fixed address.

The cable from my existing hub connects into the WAN port, so my LAN is the "WAN" from the router's perspective and all my LAN machines are in a "DMZ".

I think I'll eventually put all my machines on the same size of the SMC firewall and rely on the 802.11b Security recommendations (for what they're worth). So then I'll have two firewalls, so I could put a machine between them (in a real DMZ) to act as a lightweight external server. For now the wireless client can access web servers in the wired LAN and it can get out to the net, but it cannot access Window services on the wired LAN.

For now the setup is:

Internet -> DSL/Cisco router (10.0.0.1) -> hub
--> 2 PCs, 1 old Macintosh (all 10.0.0.x)
--> SMC device -> 1 wireless client (192.168.123.x)

    not impressed, December 2, 2001
By D. AYER (boston)
The router is supposed to support AppleTalk after upgrading the firmware. I did that and it didn't work so I contacted tech support. I got 3 replies that said it was unsupported and 1 reply said it was supported but he didn't know why it wasn't working. I've found that it works sometimes but it is unreliable. You can always connect via TCP/IP but other computers on the network won't show up in the chooser, you have to click the connect via IP button. I spose all this won't matter if all your Macs run X tho. Also, large data transfers between networked Macs can cause the router to crash. If you notice that you aren't getting a wireless signal anymore you have to go to a computer that's wired to the router and reset it from the online admin page.

I'm also not too happy with the SMC tech support. I've asked questions over and over and never gotten a clear response.

On the plus side, it works fine for general use so you can check your email from the couch no prob. Range seems to be good but dunno how it compares to other products. Admin is easy. Firmare upgrades are waaaay easy. (compared to a linksys non-wireless router I had)

The SMC is a great solution for the casual user who just wants to be able to use their laptop in another room. Tech support may be better with general setup questions so if you don't get too crazy with it you'll be all set. I suppose it's a decent cheap alternative to the other base stations out there but I'm not too happy with it. If I were to buy a WAP again I would problee just spend the extra loot on the AirPort. You know you get quality with Apple, you know it will be supported, and you know if there is a problem it will be an easy fix.

    Router consistantly locks up transfering large files, November 30, 2001
By b starr (pittsburgh, pa United States)
I have this router hooked up to one computer, and their wireless card in another. If I try to transfer a large file (>100Meg) between the two computers, the router locks up and needs to be rebooted. According to SMC support, this is a known problem and the only solution they could offer was "don't transfer such large files!"

    SMC Wireless Access Point flawless, November 28, 2001
By samstutz@hotmail.com (St. louis, MO United States)
Purchased this device over 1 month ago. Simple installation and very reliable. Have not used the print server function. Had to download new firmware upon installation to get the full range of options. Set the security to recognize certain network cards and it works great. I recommend SMC as the way to go wireless. I also have other SMC wireless network adapters connecting PC and laptop to the network. They work as descibed. Did not try other company devices. Just decided to go SMC based on reviews. I do not loose any sleep over my choice.

    Very easy setup, November 27, 2001
By NJS Enterprises (Schwenksville, PA United States)
I installed this as a suppliment to an existing 10-100 switched ethernet network. Installation was extremely easy and instructions were on the money. Very satisfied with all aspects of this device. Use every option, setup is simple and can save you money in the long run by allowing you to turn off that PC sharing your printer! Add another access point to extend your wireless range. Great reception under 25' marginal after that when installed in houses but will not penetrate the ground. Very Satisfied.

    It's pretty darn good, November 24, 2001
By newbie wannabe (Honolulu, Hawaii USA)
Purchased this item never having networked anything before. Bought it on recommendation of a computer tech fellow, who subsequently acquired some 150 of mah cash to get it up and running. I guess it was worth it, don't believe it would have been that difficult to get it going, it doesn't seem that hard to do. One thing, my daughter was using it in the bedroom, (a wooden house) at least seventy five feet from the base station, wouldn't connect. Oh well, the ability to be wireless in our computer room alone is fantastic. Also, getting "free" cable service, splitting the signal, well that's gotta make you smile. Apparently not illegal either. Much better than the old airport station from Apple, (run a Mac), which was limited in its signal distribution capacity. (Not true of the new station) Two girls getting iBooks for school can also run the hub as well. It just gets better. Has worked well for over a month, no real hitches. Mobile access is the future. It's nice not to have cables everywhere. One interesting thing when you set the unit up. When you enter the numbered address on your browser, you go in to the hub itself. It took me a moment or two to figure out exactly what the address was. Kinda fun. I recommend it. Solid router. One thing: print server doesn't run on macs. Oh, also, however, something else it does which negates the difficulty created by non printer serving for mac: it issues tcp #'s for each computer on the router, so you can access all connected. That way, USB print share can be accessed thereby getting around the non mac obstacle. Quite a good unit. Dependable. And at the price. Would recommend.

    easier than I ever thought possible, November 22, 2001
By unknown
After months of unreliability and an all-round bad experience with Intel's Anypoint (HomeRF not 802.11), I decided to try a proper router solution and avoided netgear due to several bad reports.

This product installed like a dream - within 10 minutes, out of the box, up and running - no hassle, not even a software install. Most of the time was taken poking around under my desk for a spare power socket.

Absolutely excellent and I can't recommend it enough.

Page   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12     of Total 12 Pages


Submit your review

Submit review form is only available to logged in users.

Summary (150 chars max)

Review

What is your location (for example: US, New Jersey)

Item Rating
1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars

Copyright 2001-2007 WiFiReview.com